NHS vs Teachers' Pension: contributions and benefits in 2026/27
Compare the NHS 2015 Scheme and Teachers' career-average scheme in England and Wales. Both provide defined benefits; the right comparison includes what you earn, what membership costs and when you claim.
Which pension builds more for the same pay?
Before revaluation, NHS 2015 builds 1/54 of annual pensionable pay and standard Teachers' CARE builds 1/57: about 5.56% more new annual pension for NHS at equal pay. That alone does not establish the better overall package. Contributions, revaluation, existing rights and retirement timing also matter.
Compare standard CARE benefits
| Feature | NHS 2015 | Teachers’ CARE |
|---|---|---|
| Annual accrual | 1/54 of pensionable pay | Standard 1/57 of pensionable earnings |
| Active-member revaluation | Treasury Order plus 1.5% | Treasury Order plus 1.6% |
| Normal pension age | State Pension age or 65, if later | State Pension age or 65, if later |
| Member rate range from April 2026 | 5.2%–12.5% | 7.4%–12% |
| Early/late retirement | Member-specific factors and eligibility | Member-specific factors and eligibility |
| Employer payments | Fund the scheme; they are not individual investment-pot contributions. | |
Revaluation depends on active/deferred status, service breaks and transferred rights; a transferred pension can retain different revaluation terms. Do not project a whole career by multiplying today's salary by every service year. Treasury Orders are statutory revaluation measures, not a forecast return.
Member contribution bands from 1 April 2026
Read each scheme's columns independently: the thresholds do not align. The relevant rate applies to pensionable pay, rather than being a marginal income-tax band. NHS uses relevant actual annual pensionable pay; Teachers' rates depend on earnings in the pay period. Multiple posts and practitioner rules can differ.
| NHS pensionable pay | NHS rate | Teachers’ annual salary rate | Teachers’ rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Up to £13,259 | 5.2% | Up to £36,198.99 | 7.4% |
| £13,260–£28,854 | 6.5% | £36,199–£48,727.99 | 8.9% |
| £28,855–£35,155 | 8.3% | £48,728–£57,776.99 | 9.9% |
| £35,156–£52,778 | 9.8% | £57,777–£76,572.99 | 10.5% |
| £52,779–£67,668 | 10.7% | £76,573–£104,413.99 | 11.6% |
| £67,669 and above | 12.5% | £104,414 and above | 12% |
Worked example: one pensionable year at £45,000
Assume constant actual pensionable pay of £45,000, standard CARE accrual and ordinary membership rates throughout the year. No revaluation, optional enhancements, tax relief, claim-age adjustment or pension-for-cash exchange is included.
NHS 2015
New annual pension: £833.33
£45,000 ÷ 54; before later revaluation.
Gross member contributions: £4,410.00
9.8% of £45,000; before tax relief.
Teachers’ CARE
New annual pension: £789.47
£45,000 ÷ 57; before later revaluation.
Gross member contributions: £4,005.00
8.9% of £45,000; before tax relief.
The NHS example earns £43.86 more annual pension from that one year, while gross contributions are £405.00 higher. Pension income and contributions are different measures. This is neither a lifetime-value calculation nor a take-home-pay comparison.
Retirement ages, earlier rights and transfers
Normal age is when the relevant benefit can ordinarily be taken unreduced; minimum access age is different. Neither State Pension age nor normal pension age is universally 67. Legacy sections can have other normal ages and protected rights. Early-retirement reductions are not a flat 5% per year.
Teachers' minimum age generally rises to 57 on 6 April 2028 for entrants without protection. Members with scheme service before 4 November 2021 retain a protected age of 55 under the stated conditions. Check NHS access rules separately; an age chosen in an illustration is not an eligibility decision.
A move between employers does not make a transfer automatic or necessarily preferable. Ask the receiving administrator for written eligibility, deadlines and a benefit comparison. Teachers' Club rules count from first eligibility to join and require several steps within the relevant 12-month period; service-gap conditions also apply. There is no guaranteed non-Club fallback after the deadline.
Check each statement for legacy service, McCloud remedy alternatives and transferred benefits. Do not count two alternatives for the same service. Ask for official estimates at the same claim date before comparing the total package.
Explore the NHS pension illustration and estimate guidance. For teachers, use Teachers' Pensions member services for your record and official benefit information. Scheme membership depends on eligible employment; not every lecturer belongs to Teachers' Pensions.
NHS vs Teachers' Pension — common questions
What's Next?
Not sure which calculators you need?
Answer 7 quick questions and we'll show you exactly which UK costs apply to your situation. Takes under 60 seconds.